Not sure if these indicate autocorrect or brain freeze, but funny.
Unrelated, here’s a trailer for a movie about City Gardens, a club in Trenton, that I knew nothing about until today.
Not sure if these indicate autocorrect or brain freeze, but funny.
Unrelated, here’s a trailer for a movie about City Gardens, a club in Trenton, that I knew nothing about until today.
Here are some thoughts about streaming and recorded music from recent reading. In some sense, this is a dump of links for future reference, but I hope I connect some dots, too.
Ben Sisario told the story, in yesterday’s New York Times, of a songwriter name Perrin Lamb, whose independently released song ended up in a popular playlist on Spotify and earned him $40,000.
Which reminded me of Rosanne Cash’s comment that 600,000 Spotify streams earned her $104. She called streaming “dressed up piracy,” but I think she misses what’s happening here. The streaming services are often owned, at least in part, by the big three labels, and the labels collect money and distribute it to their artists (while taking their own cut, just as they did off records). As the artist in Sisario’s story shows, if you don’t have a label more money passes through to you.
One problem with the idea that streaming services are ripping off artists is that the streaming services are all losing money. Pandora announced huge losses this past quarter, plus ended settling with music publishers for three times the cost it want to pay for the rights to stream music written before 1972. Pandora has tens of millions of customers. If it’s still losing huge numbers and it’s costs are going up, how is it going to survive? Spotify is in a similar position, losing lots of dough despite being the leader in subscribers.
Making money on recorded music, this guy Philip Kaplan argues, was a historical accident. Records were meant to be a spur to get people to buy record players, but the software companies that eventually emerged figured out ways to make more money selling copies of music than the machines to play it on. Streaming services, Kaplan argues, are simply restoring market efficiency to a process that was exploited by the labels.
A guy who has a blog called Startups and Shit, pointed me to a NY Times article from 2007 about how cultural hits, like hit songs, happen. According to the experiment Duncan Watts writes about, predicting hits is so hard because there is no single line of taste that hits have to cross. Not quality, not simpleness, not nothing. In fact, hits erupt out of apparent quality blips, in which a small network likes something which somewhat randomly spreads to other related networks simultaneously. When enough networks light up, there it is, a hit!
These network explosions amplify the perceived quality of the hits, though objective analysis among any of the individuals in the network would show a small advantage in quality. Watts calls this a “rich get richer effect.” Watts writes:
This, obviously, presents challenges for producers and publishers — but it also has a more general significance for our understanding of how cultural markets work. Even if you think most people are tasteless or ignorant, it’s natural to believe that successful songs, movies, books and artists are somehow “better,” at least in the democratic sense of a competitive market, than their unsuccessful counterparts, that Norah Jones and Madonna deserve to be as successful as they are if only because “that’s what the market wanted.” What our results suggest, however, is that because what people like depends on what they think other people like, what the market “wants” at any point in time can depend very sensitively on its own history: there is no sense in which it simply “reveals” what people wanted all along. In such a world, in fact, the question “Why did X succeed?” may not have any better answer than the one given by the publisher of Lynne Truss’s surprise best seller, “Eats, Shoots & Leaves,” who, when asked to explain its success, replied that “it sold well because lots of people bought it.”
The Startups and Shit piece links the hitmaking effect of networks with the network the major labels control most tightly, namely radio.
His suggestion for the streaming services is to sign their own artists and try to break them on their own radio services, much the way Perrin Lamb, who surprisingly earned $40,000 for a song from an album that wasn’t even on Spotify when it broke on Spotify.
In this way, Spotify and other services, could break the discovery grip of the labels on radio, and arrange to get more money to artists at a lower cost. Win win.
Well, not for the labels.
This leads us back to Philip Kaplan, whose piece ends with a link to a band called Extinction Level Event’s lead guitarless metal viral hit, Entropy, and to his own band’s self produced and promoted metal band, Butchers of the Frontier. Rockers, he says, from recording, promoting, selling tickets and merchandise, are doing it for themselves, as they should be.
I heard this on the radio this morning while parking the car. Hammond Jr. was the guitarist in the Strokes, and he also plays keyboards and writes songs.
The video for this song is opaque and diminishes the tune, I think, so ignore it, but as a commenter on YouTube says, this is like the Strokes with a different vocalist. That’s something to like. As is the chorus, which is big and bountiful.
This version is way better.
IGNORED OBSCURED RESTORED
Back in college my roommates and I had a routine. After we finished our studies each night we would unwind by listening to a few of our favorite records. We would turn on a black light or light a few candles. We would sit in the darkness and listen intently (and at a very high volume) to a handful of songs that always did the trick for us. In those days, most of what fit the bill was songs by jam bands or prog rock. A few that I can remember were:
Jethro Tull – “Thick as a Brick”
Jefferson Airplane – “Feels So Good” (live from Thirty Seconds over Winterland)
Yes – “And You And I”
The last one I recall is today’s SotW, “Song for America” by Kansas (1975).
“Song for America” was exactly the kind of cut we were looking for – long (almost 10 minutes), progressive rock with several movements, odd time signatures and some top notch, virtuoso playing. This is a well-conceived and executed composition written by Kerry Livgren.
It opens with a long three part intro. The first part has a heavy riff that slows for a synthy transitional part about 2 minutes in. The third section introduces the melody for the first couple of verses sung powerfully by Steve Walsh. The second two verses have a totally different melody. Just after the 5 minute mark the vocals are over and the song moves into the full on prog rock section that includes a nifty violin solo by Rob Steinhardt. When that middle section concludes there’s a return to the main theme for one final vocal verse and then the very Yes-like fade out. Phil Ehart’s drum work is outstanding throughout.
The song’s lyrics play on an ecological theme. Initially it expounds on the virtues of our land’s pristine, natural beauty. By the end it is distraught by the overpopulation and overbuilding that destroyed our paradise.
If all you know about Kansas is “Carry on My Wayward Son” and/or “Dust in the Wind,” you may turn your nose up to today’s SotW selection. That would be a mistake.
Enjoy… until next week.
This track wasn’t released until 1969, two years after Redding died. More brilliant sounds, melding soca rhythms and horns with his own decidedly rustic vocals. It didn’t hit, but it sure sounds like it should have.
This is what you should buy everyone on your list.
Soul Manifesto 1964-1970 (12CD)
Included in this massive set is one of my favorites, King & Queen, with Carla Thomas. Redding and Thomas was an arranged match, the notion of producer Jim Stewart to pair Otis’s country grit with Thomas’s schooled chops, working off the Marvin Gaye/Tammi Terrell template. That may be the charm, but what I hear on these recordings is lots of air in the arrangements, sharp tough playing (dig the crazy drums on Lovey Dovey) and singers who love singing. Thank you very much.
Fug melody. You don’t need it.
But it helps!
This is rock that doesn’t really roll. But it sounds.
My question. This may not top charts, but how can you discount this one?
“I bet two dollars on her nose, one dollar on her tail, if she don’t win by a nose she’s bound to win by her tail.” All the DFS gambling talk makes me wanna go to the track with Champion Jack Dupree. Jack played the percentages cannily by moving to Europe in 1960. He died in 1992 at the age of 78 or 82 maybe.
The Bo Diddley original is something of a calypso, but the Dolls don’t bite on that. Their version rocks, and what most impresses in this clip is how hard these guys work the harmonies and the front line attack. That’s music.
While the pumps, and the balance they require, are rock.
Syl’s face paint seems to presage Kiss’s face paint, which Kiss started wearing around the same time. I don’t know the history here.
Is it more likely that Kiss copied the Dolls? Or the Dolls copied Kiss? Remember that the Dolls’ biggest hit was Looking for a Kiss, before Kiss even had a hit.
Here’s the Bo Diddley original: