Ignored Obscured Restored
Back in the early 1970s, one of my cousins introduced me to the music of Ellen McIlwaine. At the time, McIlwaine was a singer-songwriter making the rounds in New York’s Greenwich Village, earning a reputation for her dazzling slide guitar work and inventive use of harmonics.
Like many artists who never quite received the recognition they deserved, she gradually faded from my radar. Recently, however, her name resurfaced in my memory, prompting me to revisit her catalog. What I found was a reminder of just how original — and ahead of her time — she really was.
One of the first songs that appears on Spotify’s list of her most popular recordings is her extraordinary interpretation of Blind Faith’s “Can’t Find My Way Home” from her 1972 album Honky Tonk Angel.
The performance showcases everything that made McIlwaine unique. Her fluid slide guitar lines weave around a rich bed of harmonics, while her expressive voice transforms Steve Winwood’s melancholy classic into something entirely her own. Listening to it today, I’m reminded of Karen Dalton’s ability to sound both vulnerable and commanding at the same time.
By the following year, on We the People (1973), McIlwaine was pushing her music even further. The album’s opening track, “Ain’t No Two Ways About It (It’s Love),” features a vocal style that blends blues, folk, and African-inspired rhythmic chanting into something difficult to categorize. It sounds startlingly modern more than fifty years later.
In fact, her vocals on the track immediately brought Merrill Garbus of tUnE-yArDs to mind. The resemblance is striking enough to raise an intriguing question: has Garbus ever heard these recordings? Given the adventurous vocal techniques and rhythmic approach that both artists employ, the connection is hard to ignore.
McIlwaine’s career never followed the trajectory her talent seemed to promise. Yet revisiting these recordings today, it’s easy to hear why musicians and dedicated record collectors continue to speak of her with such admiration. She occupied a musical space all her own, drawing from blues, folk, rock, and global influences long before such cross-pollination became commonplace.
I’m glad I rediscovered Ellen McIlwaine. Though she passed away in 2021, her recordings remain vibrant, adventurous, and surprisingly contemporary. If there is such a thing as a musical buried treasure, McIlwaine’s catalog surely qualifies — waiting patiently for a new generation of listeners to uncover it.
Enjoy… until next week.
