Ignored Obscured Restored
Forty-nine years ago, in November 1977, I saw the British band Dr. Feelgood open for progressive rockers Gentle Giant at the Paradise Theatre in Boston. It was part of a three-night stand that, in retrospect, ranks as one of the more peculiar stylistic pairings in rock history: Dr. Feelgood’s stripped-down, high-energy pub R&B going head-to-head with Gentle Giant’s intricate, classically tinged prog rock.
I can’t recall which of the three nights I attended, but I do remember the Gentle Giant audience being decidedly hostile toward the opening act. Accounts documented on the Gentle Giant Tour History website suggest the hostility was more than just a matter of musical differences:
- Night 1 (November 11): Dr. Feelgood were reportedly booed offstage about 20 minutes into their set following a confrontation with audience members near the front, involving thrown ice cubes and spitting.
- Night 2 (November 12): They returned for a tighter, roughly 40-minute set featuring songs from Be Seeing You and Sneakin’ Suspicion, including “She’s a Wind Up,” “Baby Jane,” and “Going Back Home.”
- Night 3 (November 13): By the third night, the heckling reportedly began almost as soon as Dr. Feelgood plugged in.
I clearly remember not enjoying Dr. Feelgood’s performance. But musical tastes have a way of evolving, and I’ve since developed a much greater appreciation for the band’s raw, no-frills approach to rock and roll. So, in the spirit of second chances, today’s SotW is “Baby Jane.”
Originally recorded in 1969 by Chicago soul singer Otis Clay, “Baby Jane” is an upbeat, horn-driven floor-filler that became a favorite in England’s Northern Soul scene. It’s easy to imagine Dr. Feelgood encountering the song through that scene and recognizing its potential for a high-octane rock and roll treatment.
Produced by Nick Lowe, Dr. Feelgood’s 1977 version transforms the original into a frantic, harmonica-fueled pub rock stomper. Both recordings retain the song’s central theme of regret and reconciliation, but they take dramatically different approaches in their instrumentation, vocal delivery, and overall feel.
Clay delivers the song with an extraordinary dynamic range, punctuating the chorus with soaring high notes and raw, gospel-inflected cries that give the lyrics an unmistakable emotional urgency. Dr. Feelgood frontman Lee Brilleaux takes a different route, dispensing with the soulman’s vocal flourishes in favor of an urgent, rough-edged rock and roll bark. Where Clay brings the emotional heat, Brilleaux brings the barroom swagger.
The Paradise Theatre experience apparently wasn’t an isolated incident. After enduring similarly hostile receptions at other stops, Dr. Feelgood had had enough. On November 16, after a performance in Hempstead, New York, they abruptly abandoned the tour and headed home early.
Looking back, I was clearly on the wrong side of the musical divide in 1977. I may not have thrown any ice cubes, but I certainly wasn’t cheering Dr. Feelgood on, either. Forty-nine years later, I’m happy to admit the error of my ways. Consider this installment of the SotW a belated apology to Lee Brilleaux and the boys. Better late than never.
Enjoy… until next week.