Night Music: St. Paul & the Broken Bones, “I’ve Been Loving You (too Long to Stop Now)”

One thing about the core of us here at the Remnants is that we all became friends thanks to baseball: in particular fantasy baseball.

And, maybe there is something about how our respective and collective brains process, that makes it so that while we all do love baseball and games, there are a bunch of other things we all love, and are happy to discuss ad naseum.

Like music.

So, when our good buddy from Rotowire, Derek Van Riper, asked me if I was familiar with St. Paul & the Broken Bones, I had to plead ignorance, but that did not last too long.

I did a YouTube search, and found a song entitled Call Me, which was pretty good. It also reminded me so much of the late great wonderful Otis Redding, and his band the Barkays, who sadly died in a plane crash in December of 1967.

And, as I finished watching the Call Me video, what did I spot but a live cover of the band performing Redding’s wonderful I’ve Been Loving You (too Long to Stop Now).

Now, to be fair, my love of Redding and that song tracks back to a pair of vintage all time classic albums: Otis Redding Live in Europe, and Jimi Hendrix & Otis Redding Live at Monterey (which made my essential 50 albums list).

So, the fact that Paul Janeway (St. Paul) and his crew pretty deftly pull off their homage and sound is high praise. I mean, these guys really have the essence of the Stax/Volt sound down.

Here is the band covering Otis:

And, as a means of comparison, here is Otis and the Barkays at the peak of their form at the Monterey International Pop Music Festival, just about six months before they perished.

Otis is so good and cool, and his band is so tight that it is hard to imagine anyone even trying what St. Paul and mates did. They certainly get props from me. Thanks DVR!




9 thoughts on “Night Music: St. Paul & the Broken Bones, “I’ve Been Loving You (too Long to Stop Now)”

  1. I don’t know. The fact that they look like TOUT Wars is a big turnoff for me (is that David Appleman from Fangraphs on bass?). I’ll take The Commitments for my fake soul.

  2. Rules of Rock:

    One nerd in the band – cool, especially a girl.
    Two nerds in the band – acceptable.
    Three or more nerds in the band – no.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.